Try Better Bookshelf free — catalog your first 50 books, no sign-up.

Guide

The 6 best Goodreads alternatives in 2026

Goodreads has been running on fumes for years — an aging app, an Amazon-owned database of your reading life, and a cataloging experience that fights you at every step. The good news: the alternatives have never been better. Here's an honest look at the six worth considering, including what each one does best, where it falls short, and what it costs.

Last updated: September 2026. Pricing and features gathered from each app's public listing and documentation.

Why readers are leaving Goodreads

It's owned by Amazon

Goodreads has been an Amazon property since 2013. Your shelves, ratings, and reading history live on Amazon's servers and feed Amazon's recommendation machine. For a lot of readers, that alone is reason enough to move.

The app barely changed in a decade

The barcode scanner is unreliable, search is slow, and cataloging a physical collection — the thing many people actually want — has never been a priority. Goodreads is a social network that forgot to be a library tool.

Ads and a noisy social layer

Between promoted books, giveaway spam, and review pile-ons, the reading experience takes a back seat. Many readers just want a quiet, private record of their own library.

Your data is hard to get out

The CSV export exists but it's clunky, incomplete, and easy to miss. A reading history built over years shouldn't be locked in anyone's cloud.

1. Best for cataloging the books you actually own — privately

Better Bookshelf

Full disclosure: Better Bookshelf is our app. But it exists precisely because nothing on this list solved the whole problem, and it takes a different lane than every other option here: it's built around the shelves you own, not a social feed.

Getting organized starts with a photo. Take one clear picture of a bookcase and AI identifies the books from their spines, marks where each one sits, and lets you add the matches to your library together; uncertain ones you identify by barcode, title, or a book you already own. Later, search a title and the app opens that shelf photo with the spine highlighted and the books beside it. For single books, barcode scanning catalogs one in about a second from a four-source lookup (Google Books, ISBNdb, and OpenLibrary twice over).

It also brings your reading life together: physical books, Kindle, and Audible merge into a single entry with format badges, and your Kindle highlights sync in via Readwise, attached to the books they came from. Your catalog stops being an inventory list and becomes a record of what each book gave you.

And it's private by design. No sign-up, no ads. Your library and shelf photos live on your phone, backed up to your own Google Drive with one tap, exportable to CSV anytime. Free for your first 50 books; a one-time US$29.99 Unlimited upgrade removes the limit and includes six whole-shelf AI scans. No subscription.

Strengths

Whole-shelf AI scanning: one photo identifies a bookcase and records where each book sits
Find on shelf: search a title and see it highlighted in your saved shelf photo
Physical + Kindle + Audible unified into one library, with Readwise highlights on your shelf
No sign-up; your library stays on your device and your own Google Drive
Imports your Goodreads CSV export directly — switching takes minutes
One-time purchase, not a subscription

Trade-offs

–No social features or friend reviews — it's deliberately a private library, not a network
–No mood-based recommendations like StoryGraph
–Whole-shelf AI scanning is a paid feature and needs an internet connection

Price: Free up to 50 books, then US$29.99 one-time (6 AI shelf scans included); 6-scan packs US$10

2. Best for reading stats and mood-based recommendations

The StoryGraph

StoryGraph is the most popular Goodreads refugee camp, and deservedly so. Its mood and pacing tags, reading stats, and recommendation engine are genuinely better than anything Goodreads offers, and it can import your Goodreads history.

Where it falls short is the physical library: there's no barcode scanner, no lending tracker, and no real concept of cataloging books you own versus books you've read. It tracks your reading life, not your bookshelf.

Strengths

Excellent mood/pacing-based recommendations and reading statistics
Imports from Goodreads
Active, friendly community without the Goodreads noise

Trade-offs

–No barcode scanner and no physical-collection management
–Requires an account; your data lives in their cloud
–Advanced stats need a Plus subscription

Price: Free; Plus subscription for advanced features

3. Best for bibliophiles who care about editions and printings

LibraryThing

LibraryThing is the veteran: deep edition-level metadata, serious cataloging chops, and a knowledgeable community. It's now completely free.

The trade-off is a dated interface and a learning curve. The mobile apps feel like an afterthought, and casual users often find it more tool than pleasure.

Strengths

Deepest bibliographic metadata of any option — editions, printings, Library of Congress data
Completely free
Long-standing, knowledgeable community

Trade-offs

–Dated interface; steeper learning curve
–Weak mobile experience
–Account required, data in their cloud

Price: Free

4. Best for cataloging mixed media (books, movies, games)

Libib

Libib handles books, movies, music, and video games in one place, with barcode scanning and a clean web interface. Small lending libraries — churches, classrooms, offices — are its sweet spot.

It's web-dependent, though: no offline mode, an account is mandatory, and the free tier caps at 5,000 items with lending features behind a Pro subscription.

Strengths

Catalogs movies, music, and games alongside books
Solid barcode scanning and clean web app
Good for small organizational libraries

Trade-offs

–Web-dependent — no offline use
–Lending tracker is Pro-only
–Account required, data in their cloud

Price: Free up to 5,000 items; Pro subscription for lending and more

5. Best for iPhone-only users who want simple cataloging

BookBuddy

BookBuddy is a capable, long-running iOS cataloging app with barcode scanning, a lending tracker, and iCloud sync. If you live entirely in the Apple ecosystem it's a reasonable choice.

It's Apple-only and will stay that way, the scanner gets flaky reviews, audiobook support is weak, and the pricing stacks a one-time purchase with an optional subscription.

Strengths

Simple, focused cataloging with lending tracker
Works offline; no account required

Trade-offs

–iPhone/iPad only — no Android
–Scanner reliability is a common complaint
–Weak audiobook and multi-format support

Price: 50 books free; $6.99–9.99 plus optional subscription

6. Best pure barcode scanner — if you'll pay yearly

CLZ Books

CLZ's barcode scanner is best-in-class and its catalog data is excellent. Collectors with thousands of books swear by it.

But it's $24.95 every year, forever. There's no format unification, no highlights, and cover-photo recognition is locked behind the subscription too.

Strengths

Best-in-class barcode scanning
Rich, collector-grade catalog data

Trade-offs

–$24.95/year subscription — the most expensive option here
–No Kindle/Audible unification, no highlights
–Account required for sync

Price: $24.95/year

How to switch from Goodreads in about ten minutes

1On Goodreads.com, go to My Books → Import and Export → Export Library, and download the CSV file it generates.
2Install Better Bookshelf and open Import — no account or sign-up needed first.
3Select the CSV. The app auto-detects that it's a Goodreads export and brings in your books, shelves, ratings, and read dates.
4Optionally import your Kindle and Audible libraries the same way, and connect Readwise to pull your highlights onto each book's page.

That's the whole migration. From there, cataloging the physical books Goodreads never handled well takes one scan each — here's how to catalog your entire home library in an afternoon.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Goodreads?

It depends on what you use Goodreads for. If you mainly want reading stats and recommendations, The StoryGraph is the strongest choice. If you want to catalog the physical books you own — scan them, organize them, track who borrowed them, and keep your data private — Better Bookshelf is built for exactly that, and it also folds in your Kindle and Audible libraries and highlights, which no other app does.

Can I move my Goodreads library to another app?

Yes. Goodreads lets you export your library as a CSV file (Goodreads.com → My Books → Import and Export). Better Bookshelf imports that file directly and auto-detects the format, so your shelves, ratings, and read dates come across in a few minutes. StoryGraph and most other apps on this list can import the same file.

Is there a book app that doesn't require an account?

Better Bookshelf and BookBuddy both work with no sign-up. In Better Bookshelf your library is stored in a local database on your phone and backups go to your own Google Drive, with no ads. The one exception is optional AI shelf scanning, which sends the photo you choose for identification and asks you first.

Is there a Goodreads alternative without a subscription?

LibraryThing is entirely free. Better Bookshelf is free for your first 50 books, then a one-time US$29.99 unlocks unlimited books forever and includes six whole-shelf AI scans; extra scan packs are one-time purchases too, so there is never a subscription. StoryGraph, Libib, BookBuddy, and CLZ all put parts of their apps behind recurring payments.

Your library, out of Amazon's hands

Import your Goodreads library in minutes, scan the books on your shelves, and keep it all private — on your phone and your own Google Drive. Free for your first 50 books.

See the full feature-by-feature comparison